2026 (DUQ competes)

First Round (Nebraska def. Duquesne; Duquesne def. Belmont Abbey)
Second Round (Nebraska def. Duquesne)

2025 (FDU competes)

First Round (Vanderbilt def. FDU; FDU def. Felician)

Second Round (Vanderbilt def. FDU)
 
2024 (DUQ & MC compete)

First Round (Duquesne def. UMES; Merrimack def. Vanderbilt; Jacksonville St. def. Duquesne; Arkansas St. def. Merrimack)

Second Round (Duquesne def. UMES; Jacksonville St. def. Duquesne; Vanderbilt def. Merrimack)
 
2023 (DUQ & SHU compete)

First Round (Arkansas State def. SHU; SHU def. Medaille; Duquesne def. Stephen F. Austin; Nebraska def. Duquesne)

Second Round (Stephen F. Austin def. Duquesne; NC A&T def. Sacred Heart)
 
2022 (FDU, MSM & SHU compete)

First Round (FDU def. SHU; MSM def. Medaille)

Second Round (FDU def. Wilmington (DE); Nebraska def. SHU; McKendree def. MSM)

Third Round (FDU def. Nebraska; MSM def. Medaille)

Fourth Round (MSM def. McKendree; McKendree def. MSM (Best-of-7 Baker)

Final Four (Vanderbilt def. FDU; McKendree def. FDU...ninth Final Four appearance for FDU)

2021 (DUQ, FDU, MSM & SHU compete)

First Round (FDU def. Sam Houston State; SHU def. DUQ; Vanderbilt def. MSM)

Second Round (DUQ def. Roberts Wesleyan; Youngstown State def. FDU; McKendree def. SHU; Nebraska def. MSM)

Third Round (SHU def. DUQ; Sam Houston State def. FDU)

Fourth Round (McKendree def. SHU)

2019 (SHU competes)

Championship Bracket Results (UMES def. SHU)

Championship Bracket Results (SHU def. Vanderbilt)

Championship Bracket Results (Nebraska def. SHU)

Opening Round (SHU def. Caldwell)

2018 (SFU competes)

Championship Bracket Results (McKendree def. SFU; North Carolina A&T def. SFU)

First Round (SFU def. Bowie State)

2017 (FDU competes)

Qualifying Round (FDU def. Arkansas St.; Stephen F. Austin def. FDU; FDU def. Sam Houston State; FDU def. UMES; McKendree def. FDU)

Qualifying Round (Nebraska def. FDU; Vanderbilt def. FDU)

Championship Bracket Results (Nebraska def. FDU; Sam Houston State def. FDU)

2015 (FDU competes)

Seeding Day Results (FDU def. Vanderbilt; Nebraska def. FDU; FDU def. Wisconsin-Whitewater; FDU def. Central Missouri; Stephen F. Austin def. FDU)

Championship Bracket Results (FDU def. Vanderbilt; Stephen F. Austin def. FDU)

Championship Bracket Result (Sam Houston State def. FDU)

2014 (FDU competes)

Seeding Day Results (UMES def. FDU; Wisconsin-Whitewater def. FDU; FDU def. Nebraska; FDU def. Sam Houston State; Arkansas State def. FDU; FDU def. Central Missouri; Vanderbilt def. FDU)

Championship Bracket Results (Wisconsin-Whitewater def. FDU; UMES def. FDU)

2013 (FDU competes)

Seeding Day Results (FDU def. Central Michigan; Vanderbilt def. FDU; FDU def. UMES; FDU def. Sam Houston St.; FDU def. Arkansas State; Nebraska def. FDU; FDU def. Wisconsin-Whitewater)

Championship Bracket Results (Vanderbilt def. FDU; FDU def. Sam Houston St.)

Championship Bracket Result (UMES def. FDU)

2012 (FDU & Sacred Heart compete)

Seedng Day Results (Sacred Heart def. Vanderbilt; FDU def. Sacred Heart; Valparaiso def. Sacred Heart; Sacred Heart def. UMES; Arkansas State def. Sacred Heart; Sacred Heart def. Nebraska; Sacred Heart def. Central Michigan; FDU def. Arkansas State; Nebraska def. FDU; Central Missouri def. FDU; Vanderbilt def. FDU; FDU def. Valparaiso; FDU def. UMES).

Championship Bracket Results (FDU def. Arkansas State; FDU def. Nebraska; Vanderbilt def. FDU; UMES def. Sacred Heart; Valparaiso def. Sacred Heart)

Semifinal Results: (FDU def. Vanderbilt, 4-3)

Championship Result: (UMES def. FDU, 4-2)

2011 (FDU & Kutztown compete)

Seeding Day Results (FDU def. Arkansas State; FDU def. Kutztown; UMES def. FDU; FDU def. Vanderbilt; FDU def. Nebraska; FDU def. Sam Houston State; FDU def. Central Missouri; Kutztown def. Central Missouri; Kutztown def. UMES; Nebraska def. Kutztown; Sam Houston State def. Kutztown; Arkansas State def. Kutztown; Vanderbilt def. Kutztown).

Championship Bracket Results (FDU def. Kutztown; FDU def. Vanderbilt; UMES def. FDU; UMES def. Kutztown)

Semfinal Results (UMES def. FDU)

2010 (FDU & New Jersey City compete)

Seeding Day Results (FDU def. Vanderbilt; Central Missouri def. NJCU; NJCU def. Delaware State; FDU def. UMES; NJCU def. FDU; Nebraska def. NJCU; Arkansas St. def. FDU; NJCU def. Arkansas St.; Nebraska def. FDU; Delaware St. def. FDU; NJCU def. UMES; FDU def. Central Missouri; Vanderbilt def. NJCU)

Championship Bracket Results (FDU 4, NJCU 2; FDU 4, Nebraska 2; NJCU 4.5, Central Missouri 0.5; NJCU 4, UMES 1; FDU 4, NJCU 2)

FDU 4, Nebraska 3 (FDU Wins National Championship)

2009
FDU defeats Vanderbilt, 4-2-1
FDU defeats Nebraska, 4-1
Central Missouri def. FDU, 4-2
Central Missouri def. FDU, 4-3