2001       Maryland def. Monmouth, 23-9
2002       North Carolina def. UMBC, 22-6
2003       Loyola (MD) def. UMBC, 18-3
2004       Mount St. Mary's 12, Manhattan 7 (NCAA Play-In)
                 Virginia 19, Mount St. Mary's 2
2005       Mount St. Mary's 18, Manhattan 2 (NCAA Play-In)
                 Northwestern 16, Mount St. Mary's 3
2006       Georgetown 18, Monmouth 2
2007       LeMoyne 19, Monmouth 12
2008       Boston University 15, Sacred Heart 3 (NCAA Play-In)
2009       Fairfield 16, Sacred Heart 10 (NCAA Play-In) 
2010       Navy 12, Sacred Heart 2 (NCAA Play-In) 
2011       Navy 20, Quinnipiac 5 (NCAA Play-In)
2012      Towson 15, Monmouth 5 (NCAA Play-In)
2013      Navy 12, Monmouth 6 (NCAA Play-In)
2014      Boston College 17, Bryant 9
2015      Loyola (MD) 21, Bryant 3  
2016      Penn 17, Wagner 7 
2017      Stony Brook 21, Bryant 6
2018      Wagner 13, Mercer 9
              Towson 16, Wagner 6
2019      Wagner 15, Fairfield 13
              Princeton 19, Wagner 7
2021      Duke 19, Mount St. Mary's 3
2022      Loyola (MD) 17, Mount St. Mary's 5
2023      North Carolina 16, Sacred Heart 5
2024      Virginia 21, LIU 6
2025      Virginia 20, LIU 6
2026      Stony Brook 19, Stonehill 5