| Offensive Player of the Year |
Dan Sabella, Monmouth |
| Defensive Player of the Year |
Jason Gmitter, Monmouth |
| Offensive Rookie of the Year |
Jeremy Swords, St. Francis (PA) |
| Defensive Rookie of the Year |
Daryn Plummer, Wagner |
| Coach of the Year |
Joe Walton, Robert Morris |
|
|
| Pos. |
Player |
Team |
Pos. |
Player |
Team |
| QB |
Dan Sabella |
MON |
DL |
Jason Gmitter |
MON |
| RB |
Rick Sarille |
WAG |
DL |
Steve Konopka |
CCSU |
| RB |
Archie Wannamaker |
RMC |
DL |
Jason Spencer |
RMC |
| WR |
William Holder |
MON |
DL |
Chad Wiley |
WAG |
| WR |
Fred Parker |
RMC |
LB |
John O'Connell |
RMC |
| TE |
Justin Abel |
WAG |
LB |
Nate List |
RMC |
| OL |
Brian Avery |
WAG |
LB |
Ryan Linder |
WAG |
| OL |
Chad Moran |
WAG |
DB |
Brian Dunn |
RMC |
| OL |
Brian Cleary |
RMC |
DB |
Dante Payne |
RMC |
| OL |
Hank Fraley |
RMC |
DB |
Steve Covello |
MON |
| OL |
Anthony Verdi |
MON |
DB |
Vinnie Sasso |
MON |
| K |
Carl Franke |
WAG |
P |
Carl Franke |
WAG | |