Fay was instrumental in leading a second-half Seahawk comeback that fell just short as Wagner dropped an 11-10 decision against Iona on Wednesday. Fay shut down Iona's attack in the second half as the Gaels did not score for the remaining eighteen minutes of the game, allowing the Seahawks to score five unanswered goals. The junior finished with an impressive stat line with one goal, seven ground balls, five caused turnovers, and two draw controls.